Second Critique of a Research Article “Abortion and Mental Health: Evaluating the Evidence” by Major, Appelbaum, Beckman, Dutton, Russo, and West
← Ecological Conditions Contributing to the Evolution of Early Primates | Leadership Experience → |
Introduction
The article “Abortion and Mental Health: Evaluating the Evidence” by Major, Appelbaum, Beckman, Dutton, Russo, and West (2009) addresses the relationship between women’s mental health and induced abortion. The authors analyzed the relation between abortion and women’s mental health by reviewing the implications that abortion had on health as documented between 1989 and 2008. Among the reports that were reviewed was the American Psychological Association’s (APA) taskforce on mental health and abortion published in 2008.
Major et al. (2009) further conducted a longitudinal survey establishing (a) time precedence of the abortion before a mental health variable, (b) conservation of abortion and the mental health outcome variable, and (c) control of the third variables associated with the outcome variable so that plausible alternative explanations can be ruled out. Consequently, they postulate that abortion is a risk factor related to other risk factors of pregnant women. They propose that research designs should include clearly defined and equivalent comparison groups. For instance, it is appropriate to compare only women who have procured abortion with women who have been pregnant. They underscore the problematic nature of relative risk in this assessment since, even within the abortion comparison group, abortion is experienced differently by different women.
The research work had three key objectives. The first objective was to do a review and make an evaluation of empirical research analyzing the connection between mental health and induced abortion. The second objective was to conduct a review of abortion’s mental health risks in comparison to the challenges experienced when one opts for alternatives to abortion. The third objective was to look at the causes of differences in the way women psychologically respond to abortion.
The results could be put into two broad categories. First, most women will experience negative psychological reactions following an abortion as it is a uniquely traumatic experience. Secondly, there are complementary factors that may lead to negative or positive psychological reactions following an abortion. It is because abortion and unwanted pregnancy are potentially stressful life events, and responses depend on the women’s coping strategies and resources (Planned Parenthood Federation of America, 2014). It was reported that the socio-cultural context in which abortion occurs influences psychological reaction to abortion (American Psychological Association, 2008). It was also found out that unwanted pregnancy occur in the context of co-occurring risks, which usually presupposes poor mental health irrespective of pregnancy resolution (Major et al., 2009).
From the study, Major et al. (2009) enumerate their key findings as follows:
a) Risk associated with first abortion for non-therapeutic reasons is equal to the risk women who deliver unwanted pregnancy run;
b) The mental health challenges encountered due to termination of a wanted pregnancy due to abnormalities experienced during pregnancy appears similar to the challenges faced by women who suffer from stillbirth, miscarriage or whose newborns die.
c) Mental health complications suffered by young women seem to be slightly more serious if they disclose that they had an abortion than if they did not do that.
d) There are co-relations between pre-existing and pre-occurring conditions of unwanted pregnancy and abortion. This also relates to conditions that can have long lasting negative implications on mental health no matter how the pregnancy is handled;
e) Adult women who induce an abortion do not have mental health complications;
f) Abortion is undertaken as a result of inconsistency, and it leads to a mix of pleasurable and undesired emotional reactions.
Evaluating Research Methods
The article is based on a solid literature review. The authors focused on critical appraisal, research, and writing (Mertens, 2010). Major et al. (2009) narrowed down their study on mental health implications of women based on how mental health is defined by Word Health Organization. They also analyzed literature on complications related to mental health and associated with induced (not spontaneous) abortion for medical purposes. They narrowed down their review to empirical studies published in English and pre-reviewed journals published between 1989 and 2008. 58 papers based on the US and international samples and the taskforce report, the APA TFMHA 2008, were reviewed. They also surveyed six papers that were published after submission of the TFMA report to APA (Major et al., 2009).
Specifically, the controversy around abortion and whether it should be available for mild to severe fatal abnormality conditions and non-medical reasons is still widely debated. In 1973, the Roe v. Wade US landmark ruled legalized abortion, and more than 35 years on, it continues to elicit political, religious, literary, and legal emotions and controversies (Major et al., 2009). The major debate is ongoing, and, as Beckwith (1995) notes, the major controversy is between pro-life radicals and crusaders of abortion.
The research type employed by the authors closely mirrors non-experimental research. In non-experimental research, variables of interest cannot be manipulated since they are naturally existing attributes. Thus, assignment of a given treatment condition to individuals would be unethical. This deviates from other research types such as experimental research. In the case of the latter, there are random assignments and manipulation of an independent variable while employing strict controls. Even though experimental research provides a better analysis of cause-and-effect relationships, it happens in highly controlled environments. The conditions are quite unethical when applied to women’s mental health and abortion (Sousa, Driessnack, & Mendes, 2007).
In their research, the authors used four sample sets. The first set involved a review of the medical records (where n=31). They made a comparison between women who went through abortion with those who had a different reproductive history by performing follow up analyses of public data sets. The second set involved other data from the survey. 19 of the surveys were done in the United States, 2 were done in Australia, 2 - in New Zealand, 6 - in Finland, and 2 - in Norway. The third set (with n=21) provided a description of the original studies that were mainly done to make a comparison between responses given by women who had a first-trimester abortion with those who had a different reproductive record. The fourth set reviewed the psychological experience of women who had a late-trimester abortion. Finally, 23 papers were reviewed based on the US, meeting all the other inclusion criteria (Major et al., 2009). Therefore, the sampling method used for this survey was very comprehensive and representative of the population around the subject area under discussion, and it was thus very appropriate.
Notably, the authors have documented a very practical work. The practicality of their work is demonstrated by:
1. The sampling method employed. They have reviewed the medical records and other surveys describing the original studies on the first-trimester and late-trimester abortions and their responses. The others have also reviewed the US papers meeting the other inclusion criteria.
2. Non-experimental research. This does not require serious variable controls. It also employs analyses and reviews of the variables in their naturally occurring conditions.
3. Proper literature review. The literature review examines women’s mental health outcomes and implications induced by abortion using clear inclusive criteria. According to the criteria, empirical research, published in English, and pre-reviewed journals, published from 1989 to 2008, must have measured a mental health condition subsequent to abortion as well as analyze comparison groups.
4. The relevance of the study. Abortion and its psychological impacts have been very topic issues for last four decades.
Accordingly, the authors advance the applicability of their research by identifying a number of factors associated with mental health of women who experienced unwanted pregnancy. The study has identified the preexisting as well as co-occurring conditions in a life of a woman, which place her at a greater or lesser risk of poor mental health regardless of the way she resolves her pregnancy. The result could also be applied in conducting appraisals of the meaning of pregnancy and abortion and a woman’s ability to deal with each option. It has also presented various coping strategies a woman may use to accept her decision (Major et al., 2009).
In my opinion, the authors’ findings can be very useful in formulation of public health policy to help tackle the issues related to abortion. It will help institutions to come up with both legal and societal mechanisms of addressing the issues of unwanted pregnancies, abortion, and related mental health challenges. In addition, the knowledge generated from the findings can further elicit public debates to uncover any missing data as to abortion and its relation to mental health challenges. This will help improve the quality of life.
Though the study meets nearly all the scientific requirements, the researchers’ focus on three independent objectives makes the study too broad. The researchers could not have explored all the materials on each subject matter. The researchers could have narrowed the scope of the study to do a review and evaluation of empirical research only related to mental health and induced abortion. It means that there is a need for further research on each of the three objectives independently.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the authors are clear and straightforward in their writing. They start by giving an abstract overview of the research topic. They also offer in-depth background information on public health debate, abortion, and psychological health challenges associated with unwanted pregnancy. They are equally clear in their framing of the research question about abortion and mental health exploring the variability in abortion experience. Their conceptual framework clearly outlines the assumptions guiding the study. Finally, their literature review and conclusions were equally comprehensive.
Buy critical essay online from the top-rated writing experts!
- Leadership Experience
- Racism in America-Devil's Advice
- Ecological Conditions Contributing to the Evolution of Early Primates
- The Walls that Restrict Our Thinking Process
![]() |
Sharon S.
Dallas, TX
|
|
I greatly appreciate your assistance. Writing has never been my strong point. When I needed help, EssaysEmpire.com gave it to me. I am completely satisfied! |
![]() |
Grace G.
London, UK
|
|
I was quite satisfied with the results of my paper order. EssaysEmpire.com sure has some good writers! I thought it might just be some college kids who were writing in their spare time to earn some extra bucks. No! EssaysEmpire.com hires legitimate writers. They all seem to be well educated and intelligent, too. My paper was terrific! |
![]() |
Kaylie B.
Casper, WY
|
|
Thank you, EssaysEmpire.com, for being the one writing service that I can always depend upon. You are reliable, honest and you do great work. I have been happy with every order I have placed with you |
![]() |
Billie N.
Atlanta, GA
|
|
EssaysEmpire.com is the only writing company that I can trust with my important writing projects. I have learned that I can count on your quality and ability without fail. Thank you, EssaysEmpire.com, for only hiring the best writers. I wouldn’t dream of using any other writing service. |
![]() |
Cleo P.
Oakland, CA
|
|
I submitted my order as a ‘rush order’. I only had 2 days to get my paper finished and I just felt like I was sinking. I didn’t understand the material I was writing about, and I didn’t know what I was going to do. My friend recommended EssaysEmpire.com. I had very little lost by attempting to use this writing service, so I did. It was an excellent move on my part, because, not only was my paper finished on time. It was also excellently written. I will always be grateful to my friend for recommending your service. It is wonderful. |
![]() |
Benjamin P.
Beaumont, TX
|
|
Thank you for your diligence! Your writers got it right down to the last word! I appreciate how closely they paid attention. |
![]() |
Delaine A.
Taos, NM
|
|
I had a question about the pricing. As I glanced through the EssaysEmpire.com website, I noticed that they were offering a lot for not all that much money. I spoke to a customer service person and she told me that the prices I saw on the website were accurate. Therefore, I ordered my first paper, not expecting all that much. What I got back was a brilliantly written essay that earned an A+ mark! Wow! I am impressed! |
![]() |
Bruce B.
Purcell, OK
|
|
I had a hard time articulating what my professor wanted, so I was able to speak straight to my writer. After I had explained a little bit, I could tell he understood everything. He then took the ball and ran with it, so to speak. He wrote my paper in two days and it was the picture of perfection! I am very grateful that he knew what to do and how to do it so perfectly. |
![]() |
Tricia A.
Calabasas, CA
|
|
Thanks for everything. I like your writing service a lot. Your staff is friendly and they’re always open. The papers that you’ve written for me have been very good. |
![]() |
Nancy T.
Little Rock, AR
|
|
The quality of the work produced by your professional writers is second to none. No wonder you have the reputation for being the best writing service online! You certainly met up to all of my expectations! You’re the best, for sure. |
![]() |
Grace T.
Purcell, OK
|
|
Thank you for assuring that only the best writers work for you. It doesn’t matter which writer has been assigned to my projects since I started using your services. Every time I get a paper written, it is perfect. |
![]() |
Steve Y.
Ft. Worth, TX
|
|
I would just like to say that I am tremendously happy with the two papers that were written for me by the EssaysEmpire.com writers. They were just what I ordered….only better. |
![]() |
Phoebe K.
Madison, CT
|
|
I find your writing company to be professional, proficient and perfect. Your papers are always so good! They make good reading, in addition to being well written assignments. I can tell your writers really know their stuff! |
![]() |
George Sparlin
Nashville, TN
|
|
You guys are fabulous to offer such amazing guarantees for your work. I hired you for my last two papers because there was no risk involved. That was a pretty attractive option, if you ask me. Of course, I didnРІР‚в„ўt have to cash in on any kind of guarantee, because the work was perfect! Go figure. Thank you, EssaysEmpire.com. |
![]() |
Ohjasi O.
Tokyo, JP
|
|
The essay that your writers turned out for me far exceeded what I was expecting. It even came with a plagiarism report to prove that it was original. The customer service center was the picture of perfection, too. I loved everything about using EssaysEmpire.com and plan to use your services again. You are one class act! |
![]() |
Kathy M.
Las Cruces, NM
|
|
To EssaysEmpire.com: Thank you for my outstanding paper. When I read it, I knew that I would get an A+ on it. Also, thanks for adding all of the pertinent details that I asked you to customize. You did a brilliant job. Just brilliant. |
![]() |
Steve P.
Portland, OR
|
|
I am beginning to understand why your writing service was recommended to me so highly. Everything you do is a cut above your competition. You’re really great! |
![]() |
Trilly M.
Spokane, WA
|
|
I just had to let you know how much I appreciated receiving a paper back that was of quality that high. I will recommend your writing service to other people I know. You guys do great work. |
![]() |
Greg C.
Atlanta, GA
|
|
Your writing service is phenomenal. I love the fact that EssaysEmpire.com is even open on Christmas day. You never close, and that tells me that you are dedicated to students like me who might need help over the holidays or any time. The work you do is superior to that of other writing services. I’d say that overall, one simply can’t beat EssaysEmpire.com. Thanks for all that you do for students like me. |
![]() |
Marcus H.
Eugene, OR
|
|
You’ve done it again! Every time I order a paper from EssaysEmpire.com, you top the last one. This latest one was the best yet. I truly do appreciate the fact that you offer such high quality writing. It never fails. With some of the other writing services online, you ever really know what you are going to get. Sometimes, they just sell you a paper that someone else has already bought. I never have to worry about things like that happening when I use EssaysEmpire.com. |