The Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb on Japan
← Taxes | Should Teachers Carry Weapons → |
In May 1943, the United States of America was setting up a plan of using an atomic bomb, not on Germany but on Japan. In September that year, American and British leaders consented on using the bomb against Japan. Immediately after the spring of 1945, Japan was in an exceedingly weak position. The United States on the other hand was exploring several ways of bringing to an end the Second World War which had gone on for quite a long time. One of their plans was to invade the mainland of Japan in November that year. The other plans were: to request the Soviet Union to help them fight Japan, to reassure them of the maintenance of the emperor system, or to make use of the atomic bomb. The United States of America believed that if the atomic bomb could lead to the end of the war, then the influence of the Soviet Union could have been restricted thus justifying their enormous cost of development domestically. In August 6 and August 9, 1945, the U.S. with the approval of President Harry Truman dropped atomic bombs in Hiroshima and Nagasaki respectively. Debates continue to grow on whether these atomic bombings were indeed necessary.
What Happened at Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
As aforementioned, the United States of America dropped atomic bombs in Hiroshima and Nagasaki on the sixth and ninth of August, 1945 respectively. Hiroshima was the first target at around 08.15. The atomic bomb which was dropped in Hiroshima was carried by a B-29 super-fortress known as Enola Gay. The bomb exploded about five hundred and fifty meters above the city of Hiroshima releasing an equivalent of fifteen kilotons of energy. Those who witnessed the scenario reported to have seen a parachute falling from the sky, followed by a terrific blast of extreme temperatures. It was reported that between 130,000 and 200,000 people either died, got seriously wounded or disappeared.
The government of Japan underestimated the significance and impact of this attack which was subsequently followed the bombing of Nagasaki after a few days. The weapon that hit Nagasaki had been destined for Kokura near the island of Kyushu, but there was a lot of cloud cover which compelled the crew to hit their secondary target. This weapon was about twenty kilotons, but it did not do so much damage thanks to the local topography of Nagasaki. The injuries and the damage which was caused by the two bombs were influenced by three major factors. The first one was the intensity of the blast which was indeed very large. The second factor was the release of thermal radiation which caused a lot of burns, as well as causing fires. The third factor was the presence of nuclear radiation which resulted to injuries and deaths of individuals due to damaged tissues. Each of these three factors caused injuries on victims up to 1.6 kilometers away from the epicenter of the blast, but most of the deaths occurred as a result of the first two factors. The atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki continue to elicit reactions over the use of atomic bombs. Nevertheless, in purely military perspective, these attacks proved decisive in convincing the government of Japan to think of the unthinkable by accepting defeat.
Why did President Truman decide to drop the bomb?
After the Second World War, very few people questioned the validity of the decision of President Harry Truman to use atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Many Americans were contented with the palpable reasoning that the attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki brought about a timelier end to World War II. They found nothing wrong with the killing of more than one hundred thousand people perceived to be their enemies using the atomic bomb. After all, the Japanese had earlier on attacked America through the bombing of Pearl Harbor. However, in the subsequent years, many people begun to question President Harry Truman’s conservative wisdom of trying to save people’s lives through killing and harming others, thus coming up with theories of their own. A close examination of this circumstance however reveals that there is a clear cut line between the truth and fiction as to why Truman decided to use the atomic bombs instead of alternative bombs. Indeed, Truman’s verdict to use the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki was for the purpose of saving many more lives, and to allow for a speedy end of the war so as to avert the possibility of a devastating land invasion.
The people who are presently questioning the motives behind Truman’s decision are commonly referred to as Revisionists since they continuously attempt to revise the common historical perceptions, thus proposing their own unconventional theories and motives. As early as in 1946, these people had begun to postulate their ideas, but a large number of people started showing credibility to their words in 1960’s and 1970’s. Revisionists believe that President Truman had his own ulterior motives which led him to use atomic bombs on Japan, or that he did it for an exclusively different reason which had totally nothing to do with the claim of saving lives. Most of the people who were present at the time of these bombings, particularly the veterans believe on the traditional conviction that President Truman decided to attack Japan using atomic bombs because of exclusively military reasons. They believe that a timely end of the Second World War meant that there was no need to invade Japan’s land. According to them, such an invasion could have been extremely costly to both the American people and the Japanese people. They believe that a quick end of the war would have given soldiers the chance of going back home and rebuilding their lives.
The Revisionists, on the other hand, believe that President Truman bombed the two Japanese cities for entirely different reasons. The most obvious reason according to them was to punish Japan for its attack on Pearl Harbor and for its dreadful treatment of United States’ prisoners of war. In addition, they believe that an atomic bombing of Japan was the only action that would have helped him to justify the cost of the Manhattan Project. Revisionists believe that if President Truman could not have been in a position to justify this extraordinary cost, he would have been probed through a Congressional inquiry for misappropriation of two billion U.S. dollars. In addition, he did not only wish to avoid the Congressional probes, but also wanted to secure another term in office as President. According to the Revisionists, his chances of being re-elected would have been very minimal if the general public realized that he had wasted funds and failed to protect American lives by holding a weapon that could have brought a quick end to the war. The final Revisionist assertion is that President Truman wanted to give America an edge over other nations in the impending Cold War through a public expression that they were not scared of using weapons of mass destruction.
Was it necessary for the U.S. to drop the atomic bomb on Japan so as to end World War II?
It is worth to note that there was, and perhaps there is no more controversial issue in the American history of the twentieth century than President Truman’s decision to invade Japan using the atomic bomb. A great number of historians argue that this idea was necessary so as to bring the war to an end, and that it in deed saved many lives, both American and Japanese, through circumventing a land invasion of Japan which could have probably led to the death of many more people. Nevertheless, other historians argue that Japan could have capitulated even without being attacked using the atomic bomb. They in fact believe that President Truman and his advisors essentially decided to use the atomic bomb so as to frighten the Soviet Union. According to these historians, the United States was aware of the fact that the Japanese were in the quest for a conditional surrender as depicted by the signals of the messages which they had intercepted between Tokyo and Moscow. Nevertheless, American policy-makers were not ready by all means to accept a Japanese surrender that would have changed nothing in its military dictatorship. They also believed that such surrender could have even allowed Japan to retain some of its war conquests. In addition, the U.S. leaders were anxious to quickly bring the war to an end.
It is worth to note that the period between July and August, 1945 was not a bloodless interlude of conciliation. In essence, there were still no evident negotiations taking place during this period. America sustained more casualties towards the end of July and in early August that year, particularly from the suicidal “kamikaze” attacks which employed the use of aircrafts and Japanese midget submarines. A perfect example is the sinking of the Indianapolis by a Japanese submarine on the 29th of July. Among the 1,199 crew members who were on board, only three hundred and sixteen survived. On the other hand, the people of Japan were also suffering by far during this time. Naval bombardment and air raid attacks were a common phenomenon day by day, and starvation was already setting in.
Were there any alternatives for the U.S. apart from dropping the atomic bomb?
According to some historians, there were several alternatives at hand, even though only a few political planners and military personnel thought that these alternatives could bring the desired outcome quickly. Most of them were of course for the idea that the shock of a swift series of bomb attacks was the best way to intimidate Japan. The idea of demonstrating the power of the atomic bomb in a secluded area was a decision that was supported by a majority of the Manhattan Project scientist, since they thought that providing Japan with a warning could have allowed them to try to intercept the delivering bomber. Such a warning could also have led to Japan moving the American prisoners of war to the targeted areas.
Another alternative which the U.S. had was to wait for the much anticipated imminent Soviet declaration of war with the hope that this could have convinced Japan to capitulate unconditionally. However, the Soviet declaration was not anticipated until the mid of August. On the other hand, President Truman was trying to avoid the scenario that could have required him to share the administration of Japan jointly with the Soviet Union. Another alternative was to use a blockade alongside a series of conventional bombing attacks. However, it was not clear how long these attacks would have gone on for Japan to surrender, if they really worked.
The only remaining option which President Truman and his advisors thought would indeed lead to a Japanese surrender apart from the atomic bomb was a physical invasion of the Islands in Japan. Plans were already underway for these invasions, the initial landings having been occasioned to take place during the winter of 1945 and 1946. Nonetheless, not even a single person knew of how many people would perish; the Americans, the Japanese and the Allies, but the latest capture of Okinawa provided a horrible clue. The struggle to seize this small island extended over a period of ten weeks resulting to the loss of more than twelve thousand Americans, one hundred thousand Japanese, and possibly more than one hundred thousand native Okinawans.
The only possible way that anyone can judge President Truman’s motives of attacking Japan using an atomic bomb is through a careful analysis of the outcome of his decision. No one can tell the precise reason or reasons, even through reading his private diary. Nevertheless, it is agreed by many historians that the decision was likely an outcome of a combination of many reasons, chief among them being punishment, saving lives, justification of cost and the desire to end World War II. It is however quite evident that the use of the atomic bomb saved the lives of many people. It should be noted that even though many people perished in the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (about 105,000 people), an American invasion of Japan would have probably caused far much more deaths (between 250,000 and 3,000,000 Japanese and American lives), and the war would have continued for at least four more months. It is therefore reasonable to conclude that the number of people who perished in the atomic bombings was far much less than what would have been if there was an invasion of Kyushu. It is also pragmatic to conclude that the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki brought about a quick end to World War II. As such, President Truman’s motives cannot be questioned in terms of the outcomes of his decision. This is a clear scenario in which the end justifies the means.
![]() |
Katy A.
London, England
|
|
Your writers are very good at what they do. I would recommend your service to anyone. It is impressive and it doesn’t cost too much. |
![]() |
Pierre W.
Memphis, TN
|
|
There are four things that I look for in a good writing service. #1. They have to be fast. A good writing service won’t miss an important deadline. #2. A good writing service will let customers actually talk to the writer who is working on their customer’s papers, so the customer can work out important details. #3. A good writing service will have a user-friendly website that is easy for the customer to use and #4, a good writing service will offer quality guarantees. EssaysEmpire.com meets all of this criteria and more. EssaysEmpire.com is the best writing service and has the reputation to prove it. I wouldn’t even consider using another writing service since experiencing the excellence that is EssaysEmpire.com! |
![]() |
Maddie P.
Seattle, WA
|
|
The EssaysEmpire.com website is so great! There are no mysteries to be solved. They give you the full layout about what they have to offer and how much it costs. No surprises. I had a couple of questions about the different options and their customer service rep was so friendly! She answered all my questions. I ordered my first paper and it was so well written that I got an A+ on it! Thank you, EssaysEmpire.com! |
![]() |
Patti F.
Boulder, CO
|
|
I have complete confidence in the quality of the work that I order from your writing service. You have always been the prime example of what a writing service should be. |
![]() |
Steve C.
Marion, NE
|
|
Thank you so much! I was assigned a paper that I found impossible to write. I did the reading. I did the research. However, regardless of my weak attempts, I could not formulate a cogent paper. I needed help, and EssaysEmpire.com’s writers were there for me. Customer service even arranged for me to speak with the person who was working on my paper personally. I had a lot of concerns, because my professor was very picky. However, EssaysEmpire.com was able to handle the order with no problem |
![]() |
Joyce T.
New Orleans, LA
|
|
I was trying to choose between EssaysEmpire.com and another online writing service and I didn’t know which one to pick. Then, I began to read reviews. I didn’t read even one thing negative about EssaysEmpire.com, and the other site was fraught with complaints. I went with EssaysEmpire.com, and it turned out that all the good things I had read about the service were true. My paper was fully guaranteed, but it was A-1 quality. The customer service people were great. The prices were right. Now, I am a devoted fan. When I need help with my writing, I go straight to EssaysEmpire.com! |
![]() |
Anne A.
Cambridge, MA
|
|
You dudes are awesome! Wow! I can’t believe I got an A+ on my paper! At best, I expected a B or C! |
![]() |
Mark C.
Mexico City, MX
|
|
Thanks to EssaysEmpire.com, I was able to keep my GPA up and will be graduating soon. I really needed assistance with my writing. I aced everything else, but I have always had problems expressing myself in writing. The writers at EssaysEmpire.com took the ball and ran with it! Because of them, I am going to graduate. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart, for all of the valuable assistance. |
![]() |
Sylvia B.
Lakeview, MA
|
|
Your writers did an excellent job writing my four papers last semester. I don’t think I could have possibly made it through the semester without any help of EssaysEmpire.com. I deeply appreciate the help |
![]() |
Kaylie B.
Casper, WY
|
|
Thank you, EssaysEmpire.com, for being the one writing service that I can always depend upon. You are reliable, honest and you do great work. I have been happy with every order I have placed with you |
![]() |
Beverly S.
Cambridge, MA
|
|
I appreciate the help your wring service gave me with my biology paper. I have never cared much for biology. It is a tough subject for me to grasp. This is why I needed so much help with my paper. The writer absolutely understood the whole topic and turned out work that would have made anyone proud. Thanks a million for the great paper. |
![]() |
Kyle N.
Tempe, AZ
|
|
Dear Sirs: I have just placed my third order from EssaysEmpire.com this term. I feel confident that my paper will be written on time and that the quality of it will be out of the ballpark. The first two papers I ordered from you got A+ marks, and I know this one will, too. It is so great to be able to sit back and concern myself with my reading and exams while you do the difficult writing projects for me. That is really great. You guys are a class act! |
![]() |
Shirley R.
Casper, WY
|
|
I would be honored to recommend your writing service to all of my friends. I don’t usually recommend anything unless I truly believe it to be a good thing. EssaysEmpire.com is a good thing! |
![]() |
Phil E.
South Hadley, MA
|
|
So often, when one deals with customer service, he or she is treated rudely. That was not the case with EssaysEmpire.com. The agents were helpful and friendly, knowledable and concerned. I, for one, was astounded with their competence. When it came down to the actual written material that I ordered, it was much better than I had anticipated. There are clearly some expert writers who work for EssaysEmpire.com. I would rate this writing service as exceptional, 5 stars out of 5 stars. I will happily return when I need help with another written work. |
![]() |
Gaia W.
Lexington, OK
|
|
EssaysEmpire.com gets an A+ for being the best writing service a student could ever ask for! Thank you for your continued high quality work, guys. I have purchased 6 papers from you over the last two years and they have been exquisite in their workmanship and content. I really appreciate how hard you guys work to please your customers. I’m not surprised that you are reported to be the best writing company online or off. To me, you are exactly that. |
![]() |
Delaine A.
Taos, NM
|
|
I had a question about the pricing. As I glanced through the EssaysEmpire.com website, I noticed that they were offering a lot for not all that much money. I spoke to a customer service person and she told me that the prices I saw on the website were accurate. Therefore, I ordered my first paper, not expecting all that much. What I got back was a brilliantly written essay that earned an A+ mark! Wow! I am impressed! |
![]() |
Langley R.
Los Angeles, CA
|
|
One of the things that I appreciate most about EssaysEmpire.com, is that they don’t resell your paper. Only you own it, if you hire them to write something. Other writing services that I have used, just circulate the same paper over and over, and if you get caught turning one in, too bad. You are expelled. EssaysEmpire.com will even give you a plagiarism report after they run it through their anti-plagiarism check. Such details set EssaysEmpire.com above the rest. |
![]() |
Melissa C.
Rochester, NY
|
|
I am completely satisfied with the paper I purchased from your company. I only wish I had known about you last year when I took an F grade for not being able to complete a paper on time. The work you did was marvelous. Whenever I find myself falling behind in my school work, I will be sure to pass along some of my more difficult written assignments to you |
![]() |
Sarah H.
Brooklyn, NY
|
|
As always, I can count on EssaysEmpire.com to never let me down. I had to place an emergency order and was worried that I had not given the writer enough time to do a good job. I was wrong. They did a tremendous job! Thanks ever so much! |
![]() |
Phoebe K.
Madison, CT
|
|
I find your writing company to be professional, proficient and perfect. Your papers are always so good! They make good reading, in addition to being well written assignments. I can tell your writers really know their stuff! |