Why Should I be Nice to you
← Reading Review | Executive Summary → |
Emily Raine, in the article "Why Should I be Nice to you? Coffee Shops and the Politics of Good Service” confronts the misconception in the service industry that has redefined the term good service. She clearly outlines the misconception of the term where she gives the experiences of the people serving and the customers. This paper gives a critical view of Emily Raine’s article and takes a critical look at the hospitality industry which needs a transformation on the side of the employers.
The paper challenges statements from managers of the hospitality industry that there is a relationship of trust and confidence between the employees and employer. These claims are only theoretical as stated in Emily Raine’s article. The article gives examples to support her views which are all accounted for in this essay. These examples make the reader have a different perspective and makes one perfectly agree with her sentiments about the hospitality industry. The employees are just puppets of the employer and do the job to please the boss rather than the customer all in the name of good service; where they act as puppets and robots on the job. It must be noted that in this case politics figuratively means unfair play in the industry.
Having been a worker in the services industry i.e. dining, cocktail waitress, counter worker, and coffee server, Emily speaks from experience. She acclaims that the employers of this industry short changes the employees through poor pay, long shifts, and odd dispersed shift hours (Raine, para.1). She found the work to be boring and in most cases monotonous where the workers were forced to be like robots; while the managers kept on demanding and the customers were ungrateful. As Emily explains the workers are bound by service professionalism, the heart to be nice and worst of all the fear to be fired. I categorically agree to this seeing the way service industry employees keep on making the customer happy through fake imposed smiles that are present when every customer passes.
In the name of good service the coffee servers have been made to be human robots, in the line of duty; while they establish minimal contact with the customer at all times which should be less than ten seconds so as to serve as many customers as possible. This is explained by the linear coffee bar model where each employee is assigned to a specific stage to perform an exclusive task in the service process, the employee masters the skills required in the stage and thus repeats the same for long hours making it monotonous and boring; the stages include taking orders, handing clients cups of brewed coffee, or using the cash registers (Raine, para.1). With the experience the coffee servers become specialized thus faster speeds of transactions which reduce the contact period with the customer to repeat this task day in day out.
These employees in my opinion are subjected to a very boring lifestyle which is inhumane in view of the fact that the employees have to keep on repeating not only the tasks but appealing statement to the clients under the watch of the management. As Raine, para.4 states “The one aspect of service work that can be unpredictable— people — becomes redundant and interaction with customers is reduced to a fatiguing eight hour long smile and the repetition of sentiments that allude to good service, such as injunctions to enjoy their purchases or to have a nice day”. They are also required to use approaching styles to make the customer buy more than what they came for by addressing customers in enticing ways, this amount to exploitation since they are forced to market while at the same time provide services while they are paid poorly.
The hospitality industry has advertised itself on the basis of good service which in my opinion has revolutionized the industry but the welfare of the employee remains the greatest issue of contention when the employer exploits then so as to achieve their objectives. This is the question Emily poses at the beginning “why should I be Nice to you?” In answering this question one would definitely know that the hospitality industry only plays politics which is a rough game to the employees. Huge companies such as Starbucks and McDonald have continued to exploit this aspect for their financial gains at the expense of the employees; and as the author ironically puts it that smiles are not just painted while others smiles are free in these companies.
Raine, para.6 states that “Our notions of good service revolve around a series of platitudes about professionalism—we’re at your service, with a smile, where the customer’s always right—each bragging the centrality of the customer to everything “we” do”. This to an ordinary mind would seem right but in a critical perspective it brings the shortcomings of the industry. The equal exchange between the employee and customer has the third side controlling the service delivery and has the final judgment on what the final meaning of what good service entails; this confirms that they just play politics with it to appease the customer.
The employees sometimes never cheer and smile voluntarily for the whole day, but the company management selling friendliness monitors and compel the workers to do so; and some must also continue to beg customers for more purchases through friendly means. The worst part of it is that the management sells this as the brand image at the expense of the employee. This agrees with Emily’s statements which hold the management accountable for the misfortunes of the employees. I do not disputes that good services should be offered and it is an added advantage to a business but compelling workers to it and dictating the terms of good services makes it ugly and unattractive.
Assurances from Starbucks management as stated by Raine, para.10 “not only about the good service its customers will receive, but about the great joy that its “partners” take in providing it, given the company’s unique ability to “provide a great work environment and treat each other with respect and dignity,” and where its partners are “emotionally and intellectually committed to Starbucks success” clearly explain the politics played by such companies.
Selling a product or service based on workers happiness regardless of whether the workers are satisfied or not is not a perfect strategy, it exploits the rights of the workers making them a means to an end. However the employer has always had the workers under control in view of the fact that they are threatened with being fired whenever they show their true colors to the customer. The are just puppets to accomplish the employees wishes to maximum profits yet get meager pay, minimal benefits and a career that makes them robbed off their rights.
In my opinion this is unfair and unjust since the companies also dictates most of their lives at the work place including; the length of hair, personal hygiene and perfume products, personal grooming (piercings and tattoos) and color and maintenance (Raine, para.14). They are treated as robots to be controlled and used in any aspect of their lives; and this taints the image of this sector especially where they are controlled as young children. It actually confirms Raine’s fears that it is not all about good services and being nice it is a game to get rich while controlling others to be nice. They make they public see them as mere workers who are given orders that they must adhere to with class and smiling always where the public regards as servants rather than their peers.
Being original is all that the hospitality industry needs to instill, where serving without being a servant is a more justified way that will ensure workers show their real emotions thus interact with the customers perfectly and thus add value. This companies need to style up and eliminate slavery in an industry that holds all what a society needs i.e. “best service”. This will make the workers feel valued and worth and thus translate to efficient service that is not half heartedly offered. In my own opinion Emily Raine is justified in writing the article "Why Should I be Nice to you? Coffee Shops and the Politics of Good Service” which is a must read for those who love justice and hate politics that are aimed at exploitation.
![]() |
Tom J.
Jackson, MI
|
|
Many thanks to your writers and customer service representatives for helping me get through a very difficult time in my college career. I needed writing assistance and your crew came through for me, big time! My papers were written impeccably. Thanks so much! |
![]() |
Cleo P.
Oakland, CA
|
|
I submitted my order as a ‘rush order’. I only had 2 days to get my paper finished and I just felt like I was sinking. I didn’t understand the material I was writing about, and I didn’t know what I was going to do. My friend recommended EssaysEmpire.com. I had very little lost by attempting to use this writing service, so I did. It was an excellent move on my part, because, not only was my paper finished on time. It was also excellently written. I will always be grateful to my friend for recommending your service. It is wonderful. |
![]() |
Pete F.
Sparta, NJ
|
|
Dear EssaysEmpire.com, I have never used a writing service like yours before. None of the ones I have tried previously offered the kind of guarantees that you offer. I even bought a paper that was plagiarized once. I never have to worry about things like that with EssaysEmpire.com! Thanks a million! |
![]() |
Mia W.
Amherst, MA
|
|
Dear EssaysEmpire.com, I would like to put in a good word for Writer #32412. He was really under the gun. I didn’t give him much notice because I had my dates mixed up and my paper was due sooner than I expected. He didn’t let me down, though. He wrote until the paper was perfected. I handed it in on time got an A+ and wish your writers could accept tips, because I would leave this guy a HUGE one! |
![]() |
Trilly M.
Spokane, WA
|
|
I just had to let you know how much I appreciated receiving a paper back that was of quality that high. I will recommend your writing service to other people I know. You guys do great work. |
![]() |
Susan L.
Ashland, OR
|
|
The writer who worked on my paper far exceeded what I asked of him. The paper is better than I thought it would be. I got an A+ on it! Thanks! |
![]() |
Celeste H.
San Francisco, CA
|
|
EssaysEmpire.com always gives me a plagiarism report to prove that the work they wrote for me is authentic. I appreciate this. It helps eliminate worry. |
![]() |
Quincy S.
Cambridge, MA
|
|
You guys did a super job on my paper. The work definitely exceeded my expectations and eased my anxiety. This was the first time I had hired a writing service. The transaction was seamless. I would use you guys again in a heartbeat! No questions asked. You’re the best, hands down. |
![]() |
Willow P.
Park City, UT
|
|
You guys do top-notch work. Time after time, I have had to rely on your help and I can say honestly that you have never let me down. Thank you so much for coming through for me every time. I am not a good writer. I try. I study hard, but when I need help, you are always there to give it to me at an affordable price. |
![]() |
Tiffany E.
Monroe, LA
|
|
I am 100% satisfied with the writer that you assigned to my project. This person understood exactly what I needed, even though I’m not the best communicator and the instructions were tedious and difficult. I felt certain I would have to send my paper back for a number of revisions, but I didn’t. The writer was able to convey exactly what I wished to express and he did it in record time!Thanks for everything. EssaysEmpire.com is the greatest! |
![]() |
Sylvia B.
Lakeview, MA
|
|
Your writers did an excellent job writing my four papers last semester. I don’t think I could have possibly made it through the semester without any help of EssaysEmpire.com. I deeply appreciate the help |
![]() |
Steve C.
Marion, NE
|
|
Thank you so much! I was assigned a paper that I found impossible to write. I did the reading. I did the research. However, regardless of my weak attempts, I could not formulate a cogent paper. I needed help, and EssaysEmpire.com’s writers were there for me. Customer service even arranged for me to speak with the person who was working on my paper personally. I had a lot of concerns, because my professor was very picky. However, EssaysEmpire.com was able to handle the order with no problem |
![]() |
Kris K.
San Francisco, CA
|
|
I would like to say thanks to writer #48376 for doing such an astonishing job on my paper. I really gave him very little to go on. Still, he was able to do the research and come up with a champion paper for me. I am speechless. I didn’t expect anything nearly this good. |
![]() |
Phil E.
South Hadley, MA
|
|
So often, when one deals with customer service, he or she is treated rudely. That was not the case with EssaysEmpire.com. The agents were helpful and friendly, knowledable and concerned. I, for one, was astounded with their competence. When it came down to the actual written material that I ordered, it was much better than I had anticipated. There are clearly some expert writers who work for EssaysEmpire.com. I would rate this writing service as exceptional, 5 stars out of 5 stars. I will happily return when I need help with another written work. |
![]() |
Bryce F.
Capistrano, CA
|
|
Thanks for the excellent job that you guys did on my history assignment and my bio research paper. I never could have done this on my own. |
![]() |
Kyle N.
Tempe, AZ
|
|
Dear Sirs: I have just placed my third order from EssaysEmpire.com this term. I feel confident that my paper will be written on time and that the quality of it will be out of the ballpark. The first two papers I ordered from you got A+ marks, and I know this one will, too. It is so great to be able to sit back and concern myself with my reading and exams while you do the difficult writing projects for me. That is really great. You guys are a class act! |
![]() |
Stephanie M.
Bath, ME
|
|
This is the fourth A+ in a row from EssaysEmpire.com! Thanks! |
![]() |
Royce E.
Dallas, TX
|
|
I first approached EssaysEmpire.com with skepticism. However, now, I have none. I am convinced that you are probably the best writing service on the Internet. Plus, you don’t overcharge, as so many writing services do. Thank you for the quality writing at affordable prices. You offer such a valuable service to students such as me. |
![]() |
Judy C.
Bolingbrook, IL
|
|
I have used EssaysEmpire.com for two years now, and I wouldn’t even consider trying another writing service. I am convinced that there is no other service as good as EssaysEmpire.com, and I only want to work with the best. EssaysEmpire.com has given me well written papers that have come in well before their deadlines, every time. I am happy with EssaysEmpire.com and commit to sticking with them. |
![]() |
Celine H.
Calistoga, CA
|
|
Thanks for doing a great job on a paper that was an important part of my semester. You guys rock! |